Should You Really be a Writer?

26th January 2014
Blog
4 min read
Edited
8th December 2020

I am not in the business of discouraging writers. I don't think any authors are, actually. There's no worry about there being more competition, no Machiavellian desire to stop the young and the talented from making it (whatever 'it' is). Far more, the opposite is true - writers want there to be more stories, more books, and more people making art (and here let me point you in the direction of Zen Pencils' rendering of Neil Gaiman's Make Good Art speech. It is worth your time).

Typewriter

I read last week that the average income of writers who took the 2014 Digital Book World and Writer's Digest Author Survey is £600. That is not enough to live on. It's not actually enough to pay my rent for one month.

The reality is that being a writer means not having a lot of money, and telling stories anyway. Writing not because of the income but in spite of it. Writing for the story's sake. That's the point I want to make: don't become a writer because you want to be a writer. That's a false dream and it gets you frustrated. Being a writer because you want a lifestyle or a title or widespread acclamation is not going to make you happy.

I believe authors should get paid fairly. I am not saying that you should happily give out your art for free. That's a trap only the privileged can set. What I am saying, though, is that reality needs to be faced and when it comes down to it, you're going to need something more than 'wanting to be a writer' to keep you going: you're going to need to want to tell your stories.

[Side note - this is different to the 'I write because I must! I write because I cannot help it!' philosophy that, personally, I've always found a little bit fluffy. I'm advocating writing because you like it, rather than writing because you like what it brings].

There's a way of looking at the world that defines a person's worth by how famous they are, how successful, how many medals and dollars and contracts they have. It's a view that goes hand in hand with idol worship (and idealization), and people can confuse jealousy with inspiration, and can mix up desire for recognition with passion for creation. Wanting to become an author so you can be JK Rowling or Ian McEwan is a bad, bad idea. Wanting to be an author because they inspired you to write your own stories, and because you think that others should read what you write, is a special, brilliant magic.

See the difference, though? It's the difference between following your own dreams and staring enviously at the stars while you punish yourself for not shining brightly enough. Writers can't be in it for the money, so, at the end of the day, they have to be in it for the writing.

The creative industries are going through an incredible Renaissance at the moment, but it's a period of flux where the pay of artists is, in general, going down. That might be bad or it might be good. There are arguments both ways. Ivory towers might be falling - the Internet is the great leveler, after all - but if only those who are self-sufficient can afford to make art then we do a terrible injustice to our own society and to those who might just have the most creative passion of all - the downtrodden and the oppressed. So, who knows what's coming?

No answers here.

If you would write regardless of recognition or reward, with or without the hope of publication, then that is what you should do, because there are going to be hard times and you are going to need to push through.

It's amazing when you do, though. Those are the moments to cherish.

Writers of the world, pick up your pens - and have a great time doing it.

To find out more about Simon and his forthcoming novel, Eren, please visit his website. You can also follow Simon on Twitter as @sipclark.

Writing stage

Comments

An interesting, informed perspective. My friend in the US is a successful published author (I did her initial proof reading when she was unfinanced, she read my first novice sratchings, which are still in my filing cabinet), for me its not about money, or fame, but fulfilling an ambition.

Profile picture for user narcamal_27943
Alison
Carman
35 points
Starting out
Film, Music, Theatre, TV and Radio
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Business, Management and Education
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Food, Drink and Cookery
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Media and Journalism
Popular science, Social science, Medical Science
Practical and Self-Help
Historical
Philosophy and Religion
Alison Carman
08/04/2014

As i agree with many of the words said here for me my writing is for sheer pleasure and yes i have been published many times and even had a childrens short story published, its just the enjoyment of writing i love its not for money.

Profile picture for user darcy.mc_5662
Barbara
McClenaghan
270 points
Developing your craft
Film, Music, Theatre, TV and Radio
Poetry
Short stories
Fiction
Crime, Mystery, Thriller
Adventure
Autobiography, Biography and Memoir
Middle Grade (Children's)
Picture Books (Children's)
Comic
Food, Drink and Cookery
Media and Journalism
Business, Management and Education
Speculative Fiction
Popular science, Social science, Medical Science
Practical and Self-Help
Historical
Gothic and Horror
Philosophy and Religion
Romance
Barbara McClenaghan
10/03/2014

I can only write in pencil, it helps me think better somehow...

Profile picture for user isabelst_33637
Isabel
Latham
270 points
Developing your craft
Isabel Latham
19/02/2014